Money mules are victims/agents of money laundering or terror financing. But as the name suggests, they are “mules” who have been assigned the task of transferring these illegally obtained assets so that they can pass through the financial system unchecked. Read our explainer on Money Mules here
Mules are recruited/appointed by larger crime syndicates that operate in hubs. In India, cities like Jamtara, Bharatpur, Mewat, etc or pockets in China, Myanmar, and Cambodia are popular hotspots for mule activity. These hubs target victims globally for cyber fraud, where they execute account takeovers from victims. Imagine a group of 20 people who can easily target over 2000 people from one remote town.
Unrestrained movement of illegal money can create ripple waves of damage to financial systems across the system. In the USA, last week itself, The Justice Department, FBI, and U.S. Postal Inspection Service (USPIS) took action to stop over 3,000 money mules.
If you have read our stages of money laundering blog, these money mule victims are essential for the first stage: Integration. Large amounts of money that have been obtained through illegal processes like drug sales, trafficking, bribery, etc, need to conceal their origins, and this is done by breaking them up into smaller units (also known as smurfing) and then it is passed through multiple bank accounts to mask their trail.
The Primary MO of Money Mule Recruitment
In the case of witting money mules - they contact agents willingly or accept proposals from such agents to create multiple bank accounts or to deposit cash in their bank accounts. They are aware of their role in these financial crimes and how it can further be used to fund illegal activities like the drug trade, human trafficking, political espionage, etc. These witting mules are usually rewarded in cash or kind.
However, in this blog we want to primarily focus on “unwitting money mules” considering their bank accounts are utilized for fraudulent purposes without their explicit knowledge.
Whatever the form of fraud, money mule recruiters usually have a common Modus Operandi. These unwitting money mules are victims of extreme social engineering tactics that exploit emotional triggers through psychological manipulation.
Knowing how they operate can help you identify red flags that indicate money mule activity. Here is a visual depiction of how money mule recruitment unfolds:
Stage 1: Set-up
This is the stage where the fraudsters create a fake environment to lure victims in. Each setup is a different point of contact with these victims. Whether it's online with fake recruitment scams, “you’ve won a lottery” or a plain phishing attempt.
Stage 2: Trust building
This is the stage where the fraudster will build confidence and trust. Psychological manipulation is at its best. They evaluate vulnerable people during the setup stage and then use this particular stage to cement emotions that they can later exploit.
There have been cases where victims have gone as far as attending orientation programs for the “new job offer” that they received.
Stage 3: Pitch
This is the bread and butter for these fraud rings. In this stage, they finally “make the pitch” to the victim which will start the money-transferring or account takeover process. These pitches are usually very manipulative and target strong emotional triggers like - guilt, fear and love.
In the recent “delivery services” scams that have been making rounds, fraudsters scare victims into sharing their bank details by telling them drugs were found in their packages.
Or if we continue the job recruitment scam, the “manager” might come and tell the victim stories about his mother, who is now sick and needs urgent medical attention but they are seeing technical issues with their banks.
Stage 4: Extraction
This completes the cycle for the money mule recruiter. This is the stage where bank account details have already been divulged and are successfully being used for money laundering and terror financing.
Which demographics are the most vulnerable to Money Mule scams?
Money mule scams are not a fresh problem. Money mules have historically aided and funded crimes globally, knowingly or unknowingly. As regulators upgraded and refine their AML/CFT guidelines, money mule recruiters are also increasingly finding methods of exploiting loopholes. Increased digitisation has also allowed money mules to thrive unnoticed.
Countries like India especially have a unique problem where rapid financial inclusion and digitization has arrived like a hurricane to digitally unexposed communities. The lack of technical expertise in rural areas makes them the perfect scapegoats for fraudsters. Immigrants and low income individuals are usually targeted with scams that promise quick money.
Globally, the older demographics show a propensity to be scammed in phishing attempts because of their general new-ness to digital tools. Interestingly, in Europe, these "older" mules are often willing accomplices in order to cope with rising living costs.
Since the central MO of a money mule recruiter is to exploit emotional triggers, young people are often susceptible to intense psychological manipulation. This shocking report from Barclays indicates a 23% surge in student money mules!
10 Prime Examples of Money Mule Recruitment
These are the most common examples of money mule recruitment where people get easily scammed out of their money or share their bank details with fraudsters. Most of these are social engineering manoeuvres that require quite an elaborate set-up and understanding of socio-economic behaviour.
1. Working from-home opportunities: Especially prevalent for industries where remote work is more common, these schemes offer the chance to earn money from home by handling transactions and processing payments.
2. Direct Messaging on Job Seeker Profiles: Individuals with profiles on job search websites may receive direct messages with offers to quickly start a high-paying job that involves managing financial transactions.
3. Romance scams: Scammers build online romantic relationships and eventually ask their partners to receive or transfer money for them, claiming they cannot manage the transactions themselves due to various fictional constraints.
4. Prize-winning scams: Victims receive notifications that they've won a lottery or sweepstake and must transfer funds to cover processing fees or taxes to claim their prize, inadvertently laundering money in the process.
5. Phishing emails that offer jobs: Individuals may receive unsolicited job offers that promise easy money for minimal work, typically emphasizing the urgency and simplicity of the job requirements.
6. Rewards in online gaming: In environments like MMOs (Massively Multiplayer Online games) or virtual worlds, scammers might develop relationships with other players and eventually ask them to help "transfer funds" or "handle prizes," using the trust built in the game as leverage. (Also read our analysis of how increasing taxes have indirectly led to an increase in collusion in gaming)
7. Non-profit scams: Individuals might be approached to help a supposed charity or non-profit with processing donations, especially during times of crisis, where the urgency and emotional appeal are high.
8. Debt relief scams: Those in financial hardship might be targeted with offers to clear debts or repair credit scores quickly, provided they agree to transfer or launder money as part of the process.
9. Investment scams: Scammers promise high returns on investments if the victim agrees to use their bank account to move what are presented as investment funds, often with an urgency that pressures the individual not to verify the details.
10. Pretending to be a close friend in crisis: Scammers may claim to be in a crisis (like being detained abroad) and ask for help in transferring money quickly, playing on the victim's sympathy and desire to help
Defend against Money Mules with our Comprehensive Risk Score
We help banks and financial institutions protect their customers from becoming unwitting mules and we help them commit to the global AML/CFT guidelines. Our advanced algorithms analyze millions of data points in milliseconds and are able to flag any anomalies in the user’s digital footprint. With Bureau’s latest proactive fraud prevention solution, money mule activity can be stamped out right at the point of onboarding.
See how our Money Mule Score Works
